”Breaking Amish” Star Mama Mary Schmucker Passes Away at 65 After Courageous Battle with Colon Cancer – Fans and Family Mourn Reality TV Icon

Mama Mary Schmucker, beloved star of TLC’s reality series “Breaking Amish” and its spinoff “Return to Amish,” passed away on March 28, 2025, at her home in Pennsylvania after a courageous three-year battle with colon cancer. She was 65 years old.

Schmucker was diagnosed with colon cancer in 2022, undergoing surgery that year. Despite medical interventions, her health declined, leading her to enter hospice care in November 2024 as the cancer spread. Her son, Andrew Schmucker, confirmed her passing, noting the family’s presence during her final moments.

Mary gained national recognition through “Breaking Amish,” which aired from 2012 to 2014, documenting the experiences of young Anabaptists exploring life beyond their traditional communities in New York City. Her warm personality and candid demeanor endeared her to audiences, making her a fan favorite. She continued to share her life in the spinoff series “Return to Amish,” further solidifying her place in viewers’ hearts.

Beyond television, Mary was active on social media, amassing over 35,000 Instagram followers. She frequently engaged with fans through livestreams, sharing insights into her daily life until her illness progressed. Her final post in September 2023 has since become a space for fans to express their condolences and share memories.

Mary is survived by her husband, Chester, and five children, including Abe, Katie Ann, and Andy, who also appeared on the show. The family has requested privacy during this time but appreciates the outpouring of support from fans and the community.

Mary Schmucker’s journey resonated with many, offering a glimpse into the complexities of balancing cultural heritage with personal growth. Her legacy will be remembered by those she touched through her openness and unwavering spirit.