Spring Break Tragedy in Inlet Beach: Three Concord-Carlisle High School Seniors Killed, One Critically Injured in Florida Car Crash

INLET BEACH, FL — A spring break vacation meant to celebrate the final months of high school turned into a nightmare for a group of Massachusetts teenagers and their families. Three seniors from Concord-Carlisle High School were killed and a fourth remains in critical condition following a devastating car crash on Monday night, April 21, 2025, in Inlet Beach, Florida.

The victims—Jimmy McIntosh, Hannah Wasserman, and Maisey O’Donnell—were all 18 years old and preparing to graduate this spring. Their friend, Lauren Costa, was airlifted to a nearby trauma center and is currently fighting for her life.

What Happened

According to the Walton County Sheriff’s Office, the crash occurred shortly after 9:15 p.m. on U.S. Highway 98, a busy coastal route that sees heavy traffic, particularly during spring break season. The group’s rental vehicle was reportedly struck by a pickup truck traveling at high speed, which veered into oncoming traffic after failing to negotiate a curve near the intersection with Orange Street.

Authorities said the impact was catastrophic. Emergency responders arrived within minutes to find the scene engulfed in chaos—twisted metal, shattered glass, and the haunting silence that follows sudden tragedy.

Jimmy McIntosh and Maisey O’Donnell were pronounced dead at the scene. Hannah Wasserman succumbed to her injuries en route to the hospital. Lauren Costa, who had been seated in the rear of the vehicle, suffered internal injuries and a traumatic brain injury. She remains in critical but stable condition, according to hospital officials.

The driver of the pickup truck, who has not yet been publicly identified, sustained minor injuries and was taken into custody at the scene. Authorities say they are investigating whether alcohol or reckless driving were factors in the crash. Charges are expected pending toxicology reports and further investigation.

Devastation in Concord

News of the crash reached Concord, Massachusetts, by early Tuesday morning, sparking an outpouring of grief from classmates, teachers, and community members. At Concord-Carlisle High School, students gathered in the auditorium for a moment of silence, and grief counselors were made available throughout the day.

Principal Marla Green released a statement describing the students as “bright, kind-hearted individuals who brought light to everyone around them.”

“Jimmy, Hannah, and Maisey were not only beloved by their friends and teachers—they were role models. Their loss has left a hole in our school and our hearts,” Green said. “We are praying for Lauren’s recovery and for strength for all the families affected.”

Remembering the Victims

• Jimmy McIntosh was known for his outgoing personality, leadership in student government, and a passion for environmental advocacy. He had recently been accepted to several top universities and was considering a future in public policy.
• Hannah Wasserman was a talented violinist and member of the school orchestra. Friends say she was quiet, compassionate, and deeply committed to her art and her friends.
• Maisey O’Donnell lit up every room she entered, friends said. A theater enthusiast and yearbook editor, she had dreams of moving to New York City to study media and design.
• Lauren Costa, the lone survivor, is described as resilient, witty, and loyal. Her friends and family are holding onto hope as she undergoes intensive care and monitoring.

A Town United in Grief

By Tuesday evening, a candlelight vigil was held on the school’s football field. Hundreds attended—students, parents, teachers, and neighbors—many wearing school colors and carrying photos and handwritten notes.

“It’s impossible to imagine our graduation without them,” said senior Olivia Hernandez. “They were the heart of our class.”

Local churches and mental health services are offering support for those struggling with the news. A GoFundMe page has also been launched to assist with funeral costs and Lauren’s medical expenses.

Calls for Road Safety

Inlet Beach, while known for its beauty and vacation appeal, has seen several serious accidents on Highway 98 over the past few years. Local officials say the area is in urgent need of enhanced road safety measures, including better lighting, signage, and speed enforcement—especially during peak travel seasons.

“We’ve seen too many young lives lost on this stretch of highway,” said Walton County Commissioner David McCormick. “This must be a wake-up call.”

Investigation Ongoing

The Florida Highway Patrol and Walton County Sheriff’s Office are continuing to investigate the crash. Witnesses are being interviewed, and nearby traffic cameras are being reviewed.

Anyone with information is urged to contact the Walton County Sheriff’s Office at (850) 892-8111.

Final Words

As Concord and Inlet Beach both grapple with the weight of this tragedy, one message is clear: these young lives mattered deeply—and their absence will be profoundly felt.

Memorial services are being planned for Jimmy, Hannah, and Maisey in the coming days. The community continues to hold vigil for Lauren Costa and hopes for a miracle amid this devastating loss.