WEST MILTON, Ohio — The West Milton community is heartbroken following a devastating incident that has claimed the lives of 33-year-old Jaymee M. Prichard and 25-year-old Jaime S. Gustitus of Sugarcreek Township. Authorities say both women lost their lives early Saturday morning in a tragic sequence of events that has left family, friends, and neighbors in shock and mourning.
According to West Milton Police, investigators believe the women’s lives were taken by 34-year-old Jacob E. Prichard, Jaymee’s husband, before he later died by suicide outside the West Milton Municipal Building. Officers discovered Jacob’s body inside a vehicle parked near the building, with Jaymee’s body found in the trunk.
Further investigation led police to another location, where the body of Jaime Gustitus, a coworker of Jacob’s, was found. Authorities believe both women were harmed in the early morning hours of Saturday, October 26, before Jacob took his own life.
Remembering Jaymee and Jaime
Those who knew Jaymee M. Prichard remember her as a woman of warmth, kindness, and deep compassion. Friends describe her as someone who loved fiercely, cared deeply for others, and brought light to every room she entered. She was devoted to her family and known for her gentle nature and generous heart.
“Jaymee had such a loving soul,” a close friend shared. “She always put others first and made everyone feel valued. She truly had a gift for kindness.”
Jaime S. Gustitus, 25, of Sugarcreek Township, is remembered as vibrant, hardworking, and full of life. Friends and coworkers recall her as someone who could always make people smile, with a personality that brightened even the toughest days.
“She was so full of promise,” said one of her coworkers. “Jaime had a big heart and a contagious spirit. She was loved by so many and will never be forgotten.”
A Community in Mourning
The loss of Jaymee and Jaime has shaken West Milton and surrounding communities, leaving behind an overwhelming sense of grief and disbelief. Friends, neighbors, and coworkers are coming together to support the victims’ families and to remember the two women whose lives meant so much to those around them.
“This is a tragedy that words can’t fully capture,” said one community member. “Our hearts go out to both families as they navigate this unimaginable pain.”
Police Investigation and Statement
Authorities confirmed that the tragic event was domestic in nature and emphasized that there is no ongoing threat to the public. The investigation remains active as detectives work to piece together the timeline and motive behind the heartbreaking incident.
In a public statement, West Milton Police Chief expressed sympathy to those affected.
“Our community is mourning the loss of two remarkable women,” the chief said. “We extend our deepest condolences to the families and loved ones of Jaymee and Jaime. Their memories will forever remain in our hearts.”
Autopsies are being conducted by the Miami County Coroner’s Office as officials continue their investigation.
Honoring Their Memory
Vigils and memorials are being planned to celebrate the lives of Jaymee M. Prichard and Jaime S. Gustitus, whose kindness, laughter, and love touched so many.
💐 May their souls rest in eternal peace, and may their families find comfort in the love and support of the community during this difficult time. West Milton mourns alongside them, honoring two lives that will never be forgotten.