Tragic Murder-Suicide in North Sarasota Claims the Lives of Anthony and Lois Evans — Community Left in Shock

SARASOTA, FL (April 17, 2025) — A devastating murder-suicide unfolded in North Sarasota on Thursday afternoon, leaving two elderly residents dead and sending shockwaves through the local community. The incident, which took place in a quiet residential neighborhood on Treymore Court, has been confirmed as a domestic-related tragedy. Authorities have identified the victims as Anthony Evans, 89, and his wife, Lois Evans, 88.

Law enforcement arrived at the scene shortly after receiving a call about a shooting at approximately 4:30 p.m. Upon arrival, officers discovered both victims with gunshot wounds. A small handgun was found near Anthony Evans’ body, and a note recovered at the scene indicated that the shooting was premeditated. The investigation suggests that the incident was a tragic murder-suicide, with Anthony Evans believed to have taken his wife’s life before ending his own.

A Shocking Incident in a Quiet Neighborhood

The incident has stunned residents of the Treymore Court area, known for its peaceful, family-oriented atmosphere. Neighbors, who had known the couple for years, expressed deep shock at the violence that occurred in their close-knit community.

“It’s just so hard to comprehend,” said one neighbor, visibly shaken. “They were such a sweet couple. It’s heartbreaking that something like this could happen right here, in our neighborhood.”

First responders and law enforcement arrived at the residence to find the two elderly individuals deceased at the scene. Despite efforts by paramedics, there was no chance for resuscitation.

Domestic Violence Concerns and Investigation

The Sarasota Police Department, working in collaboration with the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office, has initiated a full investigation into the circumstances surrounding the deaths. While authorities have not officially confirmed the exact motive behind the murder-suicide, a note found at the scene suggests that the incident was planned by Anthony Evans.

At this stage, investigators are focusing on any potential signs of domestic violence that may have led to the tragic outcome. Domestic violence, especially among elderly couples, is often underreported, and it’s believed that the couple may have experienced personal struggles behind closed doors.

“This is an incredibly tragic situation,” said Sergeant William Jenkins of the Sarasota Police Department. “Our investigation is ongoing, and we are doing everything we can to understand the circumstances that led to this heartbreaking incident.”

Community Response and Support Services

The murder-suicide has left many in the community reflecting on the potential hidden struggles that elderly individuals might face. As violent crime rates continue to rise in Sarasota County, local organizations are urging those experiencing domestic difficulties to seek help.

“It’s important to recognize that domestic violence is not just a problem for younger individuals,” said Claire Simmons, director of the Safe Place and Rape Crisis Center (SPARCC). “Elderly couples can face abuse in many forms, and it’s critical to provide support and resources for those in need.”

In response to this incident, local authorities are calling attention to the growing need for intervention programs and support services for elderly couples. Many senior citizens may not be aware of or may feel too isolated to access resources that could help prevent violence.

Sarasota Residents Reeling from Loss

The deaths of Anthony and Lois Evans have deeply affected their neighbors and loved ones, many of whom are still processing the tragic event. Friends and family have shared fond memories of the couple, who had been longtime residents of the area.

“They were always so kind, so caring,” a longtime neighbor said. “It’s hard to believe they’re gone. It’s just so sad.”

As the Sarasota community grapples with this loss, many are calling for increased awareness about domestic violence prevention, particularly among the elderly population.

Investigation Continues

Authorities continue to investigate the full details of the murder-suicide. The Sarasota Police Department has urged anyone with additional information to come forward and assist in the investigation. The department is also advising the public to report any suspicious behavior or domestic issues that may indicate the potential for violence.

The tragic loss of Anthony and Lois Evans has left a void in their community. As the investigation progresses, local residents are encouraged to stay informed and support efforts to prevent similar incidents in the future.