John Foster Honors Late Best Friend Maggie Dunn with Emotional Performance on American Idol

Jasper County, LA — April 21, 2025

In one of the most poignant moments of this season’s American Idol, Louisiana native John Foster left the nation in tears with a heartfelt tribute to his late best friend, Maggie Dunn. During Sunday night’s broadcast, Foster performed his original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” a deeply emotional piece inspired by Dunn’s untimely death in a tragic car accident. His touching performance not only earned him a coveted spot in the competition’s prestigious Top 20 but also resonated with viewers across the country, highlighting the power of music to express grief and love.

Honoring Maggie Dunn

Maggie Dunn, a 17-year-old from Addis, Louisiana, tragically lost her life in a car accident on New Year’s Eve 2022. She and her close friend Caroline Gill were killed when a police officer, who was in the midst of a high-speed chase, ran a red light and collided with their vehicle. The officer, who was driving at excessive speeds, was later sentenced to 32 years in prison for his reckless actions.

John Foster and Maggie shared an inseparable bond that went beyond friendship, and her passing left a deep void in his life. In honor of Maggie, Foster poured his heart into writing “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” a song that reflects his grief and the love he continues to feel for his late friend.

The Heartfelt Performance

During Sunday’s episode of American Idol, Foster delivered an emotional rendition of his song, standing in front of the judges and millions of viewers. As he sang the heartfelt lyrics, “Though we may not know the reason / It’s not for us to understand / Lord, won’t you tell that angel I love her / As soon as you can,” Foster’s voice quivered with emotion. By the end of the performance, tears were visible on his face, and his final words, “I love you, Maggie,” resonated deeply with everyone watching.

Judges’ Reactions

The emotional weight of Foster’s performance was not lost on the judges. Carrie Underwood, visibly moved, praised Foster for showing a tender side to his voice, one that showcased vulnerability and raw emotion. “I love that in this song we get to hear a sweet, tender side of your voice that honestly I didn’t know you had,” she said.

Luke Bryan applauded Foster for his genuine expression and said that his performance removed any doubt about his place in the competition. Lionel Richie also praised Foster’s authenticity, emphasizing that great music always tells a powerful story, which Foster did with his tribute.

Community Support

Back in Louisiana, the community that raised Foster has rallied around him, offering support and encouragement as he navigates his grief and continues his journey on American Idol. The tribute to Maggie has also led to renewed efforts to honor her memory. A memorial fund has been established to support Maggie Dunn’s family, with donations pouring in from friends, family, and even strangers who were moved by Foster’s emotional performance.

Foster’s tribute to Maggie has also sparked conversations about the healing power of music and the importance of remembering those we’ve lost. His song is a testament to the enduring connection he shares with Maggie, a bond that transcends even death.

A Lasting Legacy

As Foster advances in the competition, his tribute to Maggie Dunn will undoubtedly be remembered as one of the most moving moments in American Idol history. His emotional performance captured the hearts of millions, proving that music can be both a vehicle for personal expression and a source of collective healing.

The American Idol audience has not only fallen in love with Foster’s talent but also with his story. His journey to honor Maggie continues, and as he moves closer to the final rounds of the competition, his song remains a poignant reminder of the love, loss, and strength that defines his character.

For those who missed the performance, it is available to watch on the official American Idol YouTube channel. John Foster’s tribute will forever be a part of his musical journey and a heartfelt expression of love to his dear friend, Maggie Dunn.